Former PMs dismayed at Boris Johnson’s decision to scrap international development department
Three former prime ministers have denounced Boris Johnson’s plans to scrap the Department for International Development (DfID) as part of a merger with the Foreign Office.
The move, which has also come under fire from former international development secretaries, Opposition MPs and aid charities, will see the creation of the Foreign, Commonwealth and Development Office.
Ex-PM Tony Blair, whose Labour administration established DfID in 1997, said he was “utterly dismayed” by Mr Johnson’s decision.
Former Tory Downing Street incumbent David Cameron called the move a “mistake”, while ex-Labour leader Gordon Brown said it was “sad”.
But Mr Johnson, in a statement to MPs, said the separation created between diplomacy and overseas development by Mr Blair’s administration was “artificial and outdated”.
Speaking in the Commons, the Prime Minister argued that the “super-department” would be of “huge benefit” to Britain’s overseas aid mission.
Mr Johnson told MPs: “For too long, frankly, UK overseas aid has been treated as some giant cashpoint in the sky that arrives without any reference to UK interests or to the values that the UK wishes to express or the priorities, diplomatic, political or commercial, of the Government of the UK.”
Leading the reaction, Labour leader Sir Keir Starmer decried folding DfID into the Foreign Office, calling for the PM to “stop these distractions” and deal with the health and economic fallout being wrought on the country by coronavirus.
Shadow foreign secretary Lisa Nandy said the country is “diminished in the world” following the announcement, while MP Hilary Benn, who headed up DfID during Mr Blair’s premiership, called it the “wrong decision”.
A host of Mr Johnson’s predecessors also lined up to lambast the aid shake-up.
In a statement to the PA news agency, Mr Blair said the Government had made a “wrong and regressive move”.
“I am utterly dismayed by the decision to abolish DfID,” said Mr Blair, who occupied Number 10 for a decade.
“We created DfID in 1997 to play a strong, important role in projecting British soft power. It has done so to general global acclaim.
“The strategic aims of alignment with diplomacy and focus on new areas of strategic interest to Britain could be accomplished without its abolition.”
Mr Brown, chancellor at the time of DfID’s founding, tweeted to say he was saddened to see Mr Johnson “abolishing one of the UK’s great international assets”.
Fellow former premier Mr Cameron also waded in, tweeting that the merger was a “mistake” and that the reforms would result in “less respect” on the global stage for the UK.
But Mr Johnson hit back at the accusation from Mr Cameron, telling MPs he “profoundly” disagreed with the comments.
Later during the daily Downing Street press conference, Mr Johnson said it was “extraordinary we haven’t done it earlier” and argued the new department would provide a “far more coherent” way of assigning aid.
No 10 confirmed the new-look department will be formally established in early September, with Foreign Secretary Dominic Raab in charge of the operation.
International Development Secretary Anne-Marie Trevelyan will remain in post until the merger is complete.
The PM also assured MPs that the target of spending 0.7% of gross national income (GNI) on development, which was part of his winning December manifesto and is enshrined in law, will remain in place.
Mr Raab tweeted: “The pandemic has shown security, prosperity, development and foreign policy are inextricably interlinked.
“These changes mean the UK will be best placed to lead the international effort on Covid recovery and renewal.”
Aid charities expressed their dissatisfaction at the merger in droves.
Oxfam Great Britain chief executive Danny Sriskandarajah said the Prime Minister’s announcement was “scarcely believable”.
He said: “This decision puts politics above the needs of the poorest people and will mean more people around the world will die unnecessarily from hunger and disease.”
Kevin Watkins, chief executive of Save the Children, described it as “flawed”.
“During the biggest humanitarian crisis in a century, when the Covid-19 pandemic is reversing hard-won gains in child and maternal health, education, and poverty, this is a baffling and deeply damaging move,” he said.
Other organisations in the sector, including World Vision UK, The One Campaign and Global Justice Now, echoed the condemnation of the Whitehall change, while former Tory international development secretaries Rory Stewart and Andrew Mitchell have also spoken out about the decision.
The Government was given the backing of a host of senior Tories, however.
Former foreign secretary Jeremy Hunt, ex-international development secretaries Andrea Leadsom and Stephen Crabb, along with Commons foreign committee chairman Tom Tugendhat, all welcomed the DfID reforms.
Mr Hunt called it the “right thing to do” and said Britain needs to “speak with one voice” on issues of diplomacy and development.
Government sources indicated that there would be no compulsory redundancies as a result of the overhaul.
Copyright (c) PA Media Ltd. 2020, All Rights Reserved. Picture (c) Stefan Rousseau / PA Wire.